RCIM Paper Reference Benchmark
Scope
This benchmark is the canonical repository-owned comparison surface for RCIM paper-reference model replication. It has been reset around three explicit surfaces:
paper original: values reconstructed from the original paper tables;paper retuned: recovered-original RCIM models retuned throughrun_rcim_original_reference_training.ps1;RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction: repository-owned exact-paper model-bank results from the closed forward and backward paper-faithful grid-search campaigns.
Forward RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction cells must compare against the better value between
paper original and paper retuned. Backward RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction cells must
compare against paper retuned, because the paper does not provide
backward original tables.
The current RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction values come from the faithful original-dataset exact-model-bank reimplementation under:
scripts/paper_reimplementation/rcim_ml_compensation/original_dataset_exact_model_bank/
That reimplementation is anchored to the recovered original RCIM pipeline preserved under:
scripts/paper_reimplementation/rcim_ml_compensation/recovered_original_workflow/
The accepted model archives backing these tables are:
models/paper_reference/rcim_track1/forward/models/paper_reference/rcim_track1/backward/
The protocol is literal or near-literal to the recovered original pipeline
where possible: rpm, deg, and tor inputs; harmonic amplitude and phase
targets; family-wise multioutput training; restored GridSearchCV(...);
historical cross_validate(...) replay; and per-target Python + ONNX
exports. Documented compatibility repairs, such as the SVR(kernel="linear")
replacement with StandardScaler + LinearSVR, are treated as explicit
near-literal deviations rather than silent changes.
Current Archive Status
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction status:
closedas a faithful full-bank reproduction surface.retuned family-direction archives promoted:
22RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction forward family archives refreshed:
11RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction backward family archives refreshed:
11RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction forward archive root:
models/paper_reference/rcim_track1/forward/RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction backward archive root:
models/paper_reference/rcim_track1/backward/RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction forward closeout report:
doc/reports/campaign_results/track_1/exact_paper/forward/2026-05-15-11-11-35_track1_forward_paper_faithful_grid_search_closeout_report.mdRCIM Model-Bank Reproduction backward closeout report:
doc/reports/campaign_results/track_1/exact_paper/backward/2026-05-16-20-07-07_track1_backward_paper_faithful_grid_search_closeout_report.mdRCIM Model-Bank Reproduction backward completion timestamp:
2026-05-16T19:04:25+02:00ELMis archived as an operational RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction family but remains outside the original paper-family order.Closure criterion: both directions were run, accepted model archives were refreshed, and every RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction cell in Tables
2-5was repopulated.Closure does not require all-green status. Yellow and red cells document the remaining numerical gap under the faithful original-pipeline protocol.
TE Curve Verification Pipeline Directional Comparison Status
TE Curve Verification Pipeline is the repository-owned direct TE-curve comparison surface between
the accepted RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction paper-reference banks and the repository model families.
It is still an offline comparison branch. It does not replace the future online
Table 9 compensation benchmark.
Candidate Surface Contract
Every current and future model family must expose explicit direction surfaces:
Surface |
Training Scope |
Valid TE Curve Verification Pipeline Evaluation Curves |
|---|---|---|
|
forward and backward together |
forward and backward, reported separately |
|
forward only |
forward only |
|
backward only |
backward only |
This applies to RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction, TE Curve Verification Pipeline, Wave 1, and future waves. New
pipelines must load the canonical TE curves directly from data/simplified_dataset
through config/datasets/transmission_error_dataset.yaml, matching the
repository-owned model workflow such as feedforward.
Current Canonical TE Curve Verification Pipeline Matrix
The current canonical direction-aware comparison starts from the full TE Curve Verification Pipeline
matrix.
It was generated from:
config/paper_reimplementation/rcim_ml_compensation/reference_family_vs_feedforward/full_track2_matrix_template.yaml.
Canonical report:
doc/reports/analysis/track2/Track 2 Directional Model Comparison.md.
Validation report:
doc/reports/analysis/validation_checks/track2/2026-05-18-17-26-52_track2_full_directional_family_matrix_composite_best_reference_validation_report.md.
Output artifacts:
output/validation_checks/track2_reference_comparison/2026-05-18-16-35-26__track2_full_directional_family_matrix_composite_best_reference_validation/.
Grouped curve previews:
doc/reports/campaign_results/track_2/verification_plots/.
The matrix evaluates:
all
11RCIM Model-Bank Reproductionforward family banks frommodels/paper_reference/rcim_track1/forward/;all
11RCIM Model-Bank Reproductionbackward family banks frommodels/paper_reference/rcim_track1/backward/;all
11recovered original forward family banks frommodels/paper_reference/rcim_original/forward/;all
11retuned forward family banks frommodels/paper_reference/rcim_retuned/forward/;all
11retuned backward family banks frommodels/paper_reference/rcim_retuned/backward/;all
15currentWave 1exported surfaces frommodels/exported/:global,Fw, andBwforfeedforward,harmonic_regression,periodic_mlp,residual_harmonic_mlp, andtree.five composed best-reference candidates assembled from the approved per-target paper original, retuned, and RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction harmonic selections.
The latest audit confirms zero direction-scope violations across the TE Curve Verification Pipeline
per-condition table: Fw rows use only forward curves, Bw rows use only
backward curves, and global rows use both directions with separate metrics.
The RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction forward reference banks also apply the documented source-specific
h0 compatibility sign before TE-curve reconstruction.
Current composed candidates:
Direction |
Source |
Candidate |
Mean Percentage Error [%] |
|---|---|---|---|
forward |
paper original |
|
6.250 |
forward |
paper retuned |
|
4.109 |
forward |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction |
|
6.819 |
backward |
paper retuned |
|
7.572 |
backward |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction |
|
11.860 |
Best current TE Curve Verification Pipeline rows:
Direction |
Best Candidate |
Mean Percentage Error [%] |
|---|---|---|
forward |
|
2.372 |
backward |
|
5.398 |
global combined |
|
6.854 |
Forward Tables
Forward Table 2 - Amplitude MAE
Paper Original
Paper original values exist only for the forward branch.
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.002300 |
5.60e-05 |
1.60e-04 |
1.50e-04 |
7.90e-05 |
2.60e-04 |
9.10e-05 |
4.40e-04 |
6.90e-04 |
2.90e-04 |
|
0.009500 |
0.006500 |
0.006500 |
0.005600 |
0.006900 |
0.007100 |
0.007400 |
0.006800 |
0.008100 |
0.005500 |
|
0.003000 |
2.60e-05 |
2.00e-05 |
2.90e-05 |
2.60e-05 |
3.80e-05 |
1.10e-05 |
5.70e-05 |
6.80e-05 |
2.90e-05 |
|
0.003400 |
2.90e-05 |
2.20e-05 |
4.00e-05 |
3.20e-05 |
5.90e-05 |
1.30e-05 |
6.30e-05 |
6.20e-05 |
5.10e-05 |
|
0.003500 |
3.10e-05 |
2.40e-05 |
3.80e-05 |
3.20e-05 |
5.90e-05 |
1.80e-05 |
5.70e-05 |
8.80e-05 |
7.20e-05 |
|
0.003100 |
2.70e-05 |
2.30e-05 |
2.90e-05 |
2.50e-05 |
3.80e-05 |
1.20e-05 |
3.90e-05 |
4.50e-05 |
2.60e-05 |
|
0.003100 |
2.70e-05 |
2.10e-05 |
2.80e-05 |
2.70e-05 |
3.90e-05 |
1.20e-05 |
6.10e-05 |
7.10e-05 |
3.00e-05 |
|
0.002400 |
2.70e-05 |
1.70e-05 |
2.30e-05 |
2.60e-05 |
2.90e-05 |
1.20e-05 |
1.00e-04 |
1.70e-04 |
3.50e-05 |
|
0.002500 |
5.50e-05 |
8.10e-05 |
1.10e-04 |
6.60e-05 |
1.10e-04 |
4.60e-05 |
2.30e-04 |
2.60e-04 |
1.40e-04 |
|
0.002500 |
2.70e-05 |
1.80e-05 |
2.40e-05 |
2.70e-05 |
3.00e-05 |
1.20e-05 |
9.00e-05 |
1.60e-04 |
3.20e-05 |
Paper Retuned
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.002912 |
4.66302e-05 |
6.04508e-05 |
7.55757e-05 |
7.10815e-05 |
0.000121731 |
5.12823e-05 |
0.000696237 |
0.000698217 |
0.00024679 |
|
0.014562 |
0.007778 |
0.0111 |
0.007793 |
0.009778 |
0.011258 |
0.011897 |
0.008305 |
0.00701 |
0.015629 |
|
0.00312 |
2.69224e-05 |
1.92205e-05 |
2.61055e-05 |
2.2637e-05 |
3.59297e-05 |
1.05759e-05 |
4.57812e-05 |
5.27089e-05 |
3.28826e-05 |
|
0.00351 |
3.10238e-05 |
2.31505e-05 |
3.6618e-05 |
2.97753e-05 |
5.5576e-05 |
1.52993e-05 |
8.91254e-05 |
6.69908e-05 |
4.50935e-05 |
|
0.003923 |
3.39405e-05 |
2.73594e-05 |
3.96039e-05 |
2.81046e-05 |
6.39258e-05 |
1.5678e-05 |
6.23185e-05 |
6.8023e-05 |
4.45344e-05 |
|
0.003262 |
2.51681e-05 |
2.08696e-05 |
2.6821e-05 |
2.21245e-05 |
3.62432e-05 |
1.09854e-05 |
4.05968e-05 |
5.01524e-05 |
3.70563e-05 |
|
0.002887 |
2.68313e-05 |
2.06267e-05 |
2.64032e-05 |
2.42143e-05 |
3.83771e-05 |
1.19535e-05 |
0.000151854 |
0.000203692 |
5.85112e-05 |
|
0.002618 |
2.63076e-05 |
1.86476e-05 |
2.34801e-05 |
2.56511e-05 |
2.36904e-05 |
1.22957e-05 |
0.000107198 |
0.000119594 |
3.49172e-05 |
|
0.002842 |
5.29274e-05 |
5.17414e-05 |
6.83342e-05 |
6.44126e-05 |
8.84949e-05 |
4.65581e-05 |
0.000135924 |
0.000104757 |
0.000115468 |
|
0.002575 |
2.62664e-05 |
1.87327e-05 |
2.33772e-05 |
2.5798e-05 |
2.51835e-05 |
1.20466e-05 |
0.000107466 |
0.000118095 |
3.52105e-05 |
|
0.008394 |
2.88142e-05 |
7.87396e-05 |
0.000112282 |
4.01642e-05 |
0.000296962 |
2.83329e-05 |
0.000856622 |
0.001067 |
0.000369496 |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Forward Table 3 - Amplitude RMSE
Paper Original
Paper original values exist only for the forward branch.
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.003300 |
7.40e-05 |
1.80e-04 |
1.80e-04 |
9.50e-05 |
3.30e-04 |
1.00e-04 |
8.80e-04 |
0.002200 |
4.70e-04 |
|
0.0140 |
0.0120 |
0.0120 |
0.0100 |
0.0140 |
0.0130 |
0.0150 |
0.0130 |
0.0160 |
0.0100 |
|
0.004100 |
3.50e-05 |
3.00e-05 |
3.80e-05 |
3.70e-05 |
5.60e-05 |
1.50e-05 |
1.70e-04 |
2.20e-04 |
5.40e-05 |
|
0.004900 |
4.00e-05 |
3.30e-05 |
5.30e-05 |
4.50e-05 |
8.20e-05 |
1.80e-05 |
2.00e-04 |
1.70e-04 |
1.10e-04 |
|
0.004500 |
4.20e-05 |
3.50e-05 |
5.10e-05 |
4.30e-05 |
8.50e-05 |
2.70e-05 |
1.90e-04 |
3.80e-04 |
1.80e-04 |
|
0.004000 |
3.70e-05 |
3.40e-05 |
4.00e-05 |
3.60e-05 |
5.70e-05 |
1.60e-05 |
1.30e-04 |
1.60e-04 |
4.20e-05 |
|
0.004000 |
3.60e-05 |
3.10e-05 |
3.90e-05 |
3.90e-05 |
5.50e-05 |
1.60e-05 |
1.70e-04 |
2.20e-04 |
4.70e-05 |
|
0.003400 |
3.60e-05 |
2.50e-05 |
3.20e-05 |
3.80e-05 |
4.50e-05 |
1.60e-05 |
2.50e-04 |
5.00e-04 |
7.40e-05 |
|
0.003500 |
7.10e-05 |
1.00e-04 |
1.30e-04 |
8.70e-05 |
1.50e-04 |
6.00e-05 |
5.40e-04 |
7.50e-04 |
2.10e-04 |
|
0.003500 |
3.70e-05 |
2.60e-05 |
3.30e-05 |
3.80e-05 |
4.60e-05 |
1.60e-05 |
2.20e-04 |
4.70e-04 |
6.20e-05 |
Paper Retuned
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.004123 |
6.08873e-05 |
7.62318e-05 |
9.55895e-05 |
8.97431e-05 |
0.000165775 |
6.03122e-05 |
0.001528 |
0.002377 |
0.000612235 |
|
0.023068 |
0.013469 |
0.02176 |
0.015826 |
0.018224 |
0.021632 |
0.020561 |
0.015097 |
0.014136 |
0.025682 |
|
0.004098 |
3.81916e-05 |
2.78872e-05 |
3.62718e-05 |
3.33471e-05 |
5.61394e-05 |
1.8065e-05 |
0.000163705 |
0.000154321 |
5.64108e-05 |
|
0.004879 |
4.30523e-05 |
3.33725e-05 |
5.05612e-05 |
4.50974e-05 |
7.97431e-05 |
2.38369e-05 |
0.000298278 |
0.000196766 |
7.18479e-05 |
|
0.005512 |
4.98162e-05 |
4.46899e-05 |
5.37782e-05 |
4.20959e-05 |
8.92871e-05 |
2.55713e-05 |
0.000190094 |
0.000186599 |
6.97557e-05 |
|
0.004164 |
3.5925e-05 |
3.07983e-05 |
3.76465e-05 |
3.28386e-05 |
5.4169e-05 |
1.87404e-05 |
0.000144831 |
0.000158585 |
6.67768e-05 |
|
0.004091 |
3.87048e-05 |
2.7237e-05 |
3.78415e-05 |
3.57058e-05 |
5.40153e-05 |
2.03112e-05 |
0.000471228 |
0.000738856 |
0.00015009 |
|
0.003898 |
3.66942e-05 |
2.64492e-05 |
3.2727e-05 |
3.5704e-05 |
3.51107e-05 |
1.92161e-05 |
0.000264253 |
0.000275736 |
7.01425e-05 |
|
0.003956 |
6.81352e-05 |
6.50398e-05 |
8.87521e-05 |
8.33804e-05 |
0.000116671 |
5.98269e-05 |
0.000336537 |
0.000236608 |
0.000164157 |
|
0.00379 |
3.66354e-05 |
2.67199e-05 |
3.21329e-05 |
3.57956e-05 |
3.707e-05 |
1.89939e-05 |
0.000267423 |
0.000266197 |
7.02233e-05 |
|
0.010659 |
3.82909e-05 |
9.6453e-05 |
0.000153107 |
6.26075e-05 |
0.0003916 |
3.88056e-05 |
0.00157 |
0.002357 |
0.000636913 |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Forward Table 4 - Phase MAE
Paper Original
Paper original values exist only for the forward branch.
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.002200 |
0.0330 |
0.0270 |
0.0610 |
0.1900 |
0.1300 |
1.200 |
0.4900 |
0.4900 |
|
0.007200 |
0.0650 |
0.0620 |
0.0800 |
0.1600 |
0.1500 |
1.900 |
0.7800 |
0.7000 |
|
0.002000 |
0.0240 |
0.0280 |
0.0370 |
0.0740 |
0.0530 |
0.5100 |
0.2300 |
0.2500 |
|
0.002100 |
0.0300 |
0.0360 |
0.0430 |
0.0900 |
0.0660 |
0.5200 |
0.2000 |
0.2300 |
|
0.002400 |
0.0310 |
0.0350 |
0.0510 |
0.0940 |
0.0870 |
0.7100 |
0.2800 |
0.2600 |
|
0.002200 |
0.0270 |
0.0280 |
0.0400 |
0.0760 |
0.0560 |
0.5300 |
0.2000 |
0.2300 |
|
0.002000 |
0.0240 |
0.0300 |
0.0360 |
0.0740 |
0.0530 |
0.5400 |
0.2500 |
0.2900 |
|
0.001900 |
0.0200 |
0.0210 |
0.0400 |
0.0910 |
0.0570 |
0.7400 |
0.3500 |
0.3600 |
|
0.001900 |
0.0240 |
0.0320 |
0.0610 |
0.1400 |
0.0910 |
0.9600 |
0.5400 |
0.3900 |
|
0.001800 |
0.0210 |
0.0210 |
0.0400 |
0.0950 |
0.0550 |
0.7400 |
0.3500 |
0.3400 |
Paper Retuned
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.002861 |
0.039126 |
0.038193 |
0.095298 |
0.19446 |
0.167816 |
1.545304 |
0.854949 |
0.747385 |
|
0.020549 |
0.068079 |
0.081528 |
0.07124 |
0.145159 |
0.141555 |
1.653017 |
0.90848 |
0.781412 |
|
0.001953 |
0.024688 |
0.02624 |
0.036396 |
0.054711 |
0.045866 |
0.410856 |
0.234445 |
0.271166 |
|
0.002239 |
0.02734 |
0.032261 |
0.045456 |
0.07449 |
0.06362 |
0.490408 |
0.245312 |
0.287325 |
|
0.002979 |
0.032667 |
0.032921 |
0.046145 |
0.105701 |
0.077808 |
0.474651 |
0.284212 |
0.297142 |
|
0.002328 |
0.028784 |
0.027723 |
0.03521 |
0.062335 |
0.051688 |
0.400729 |
0.233554 |
0.273227 |
|
0.002203 |
0.023329 |
0.025456 |
0.037337 |
0.050657 |
0.047991 |
0.479103 |
0.298957 |
0.355748 |
|
0.001955 |
0.025438 |
0.020247 |
0.037234 |
0.071251 |
0.048207 |
0.605127 |
0.337684 |
0.391634 |
|
0.0019 |
0.025124 |
0.020946 |
0.035046 |
0.068123 |
0.043829 |
0.470111 |
0.251684 |
0.290375 |
|
0.001928 |
0.025764 |
0.020305 |
0.03646 |
0.073436 |
0.045802 |
0.603746 |
0.346318 |
0.383523 |
|
0.002771 |
0.080557 |
0.089368 |
0.067536 |
0.19027 |
0.174713 |
1.703741 |
1.116297 |
0.80237 |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Forward Table 5 - Phase RMSE
Paper Original
Paper original values exist only for the forward branch.
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.003100 |
0.0420 |
0.0440 |
0.0970 |
0.3200 |
0.2000 |
1.800 |
1.100 |
1.100 |
|
0.0130 |
0.0840 |
0.0770 |
0.1100 |
0.2400 |
0.2200 |
2.200 |
1.200 |
1.100 |
|
0.002800 |
0.0330 |
0.0430 |
0.0550 |
0.1600 |
0.0820 |
1.200 |
0.6800 |
0.6300 |
|
0.002800 |
0.0420 |
0.0610 |
0.0610 |
0.2000 |
0.1000 |
1.300 |
0.7300 |
0.6700 |
|
0.003300 |
0.0460 |
0.0620 |
0.0740 |
0.2300 |
0.1500 |
1.500 |
0.9300 |
0.6800 |
|
0.003600 |
0.0400 |
0.0440 |
0.0600 |
0.1800 |
0.1100 |
1.200 |
0.6400 |
0.5800 |
|
0.002600 |
0.0340 |
0.0450 |
0.0550 |
0.1800 |
0.0840 |
1.300 |
0.7100 |
0.7100 |
|
0.002500 |
0.0290 |
0.0270 |
0.0600 |
0.1900 |
0.0850 |
1.300 |
0.7000 |
0.7400 |
|
0.002800 |
0.0330 |
0.0430 |
0.0890 |
0.2300 |
0.1300 |
1.400 |
0.8100 |
0.7600 |
|
0.002500 |
0.0300 |
0.0280 |
0.0600 |
0.1900 |
0.0820 |
1.300 |
0.7000 |
0.7100 |
Paper Retuned
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.00436 |
0.054297 |
0.060574 |
0.132484 |
0.362591 |
0.241217 |
2.02453 |
1.654005 |
1.412756 |
|
0.032351 |
0.086326 |
0.104059 |
0.103366 |
0.212569 |
0.179317 |
1.994397 |
1.406654 |
1.202815 |
|
0.002714 |
0.034748 |
0.046435 |
0.054608 |
0.135891 |
0.06584 |
0.967807 |
0.762623 |
0.835498 |
|
0.003115 |
0.039113 |
0.060054 |
0.070673 |
0.151314 |
0.095694 |
1.225799 |
0.891606 |
0.872011 |
|
0.004395 |
0.049717 |
0.05807 |
0.071786 |
0.294988 |
0.130349 |
1.092873 |
0.927118 |
0.805299 |
|
0.003522 |
0.040693 |
0.053397 |
0.056126 |
0.156387 |
0.082454 |
0.876494 |
0.726699 |
0.769894 |
|
0.003227 |
0.033096 |
0.041325 |
0.056051 |
0.112009 |
0.075405 |
0.953229 |
0.825631 |
0.919771 |
|
0.002681 |
0.036307 |
0.032742 |
0.057628 |
0.139074 |
0.070305 |
1.03431 |
0.784113 |
0.888707 |
|
0.002489 |
0.03353 |
0.034166 |
0.056416 |
0.147066 |
0.066047 |
0.896522 |
0.773625 |
0.784581 |
|
0.002673 |
0.03642 |
0.032488 |
0.056709 |
0.145076 |
0.067668 |
1.049463 |
0.794237 |
0.883119 |
|
0.004207 |
0.099629 |
0.112824 |
0.098927 |
0.285837 |
0.233381 |
2.031703 |
1.636152 |
1.276826 |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Backward Tables
Backward Table 2 - Amplitude MAE
Paper Original
No backward paper-original table is available in the paper.
Paper Retuned
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.003417 |
7.05621e-05 |
6.44134e-05 |
0.000108184 |
3.99598e-05 |
0.000140876 |
3.55141e-05 |
0.000759711 |
0.000512494 |
0.000342361 |
|
0.016062 |
0.008565 |
0.02068 |
0.009938 |
0.009976 |
0.007135 |
0.010629 |
0.008277 |
0.011534 |
0.007464 |
|
0.002937 |
2.37386e-05 |
2.07275e-05 |
1.72732e-05 |
2.76117e-05 |
5.1867e-05 |
1.00356e-05 |
0.000117828 |
9.1534e-05 |
6.23487e-05 |
|
0.003504 |
2.69959e-05 |
3.42058e-05 |
2.59035e-05 |
3.23554e-05 |
0.000105717 |
1.36692e-05 |
0.000191057 |
0.000165638 |
0.000125839 |
|
0.003322 |
2.65069e-05 |
2.63791e-05 |
2.03945e-05 |
3.03482e-05 |
7.00267e-05 |
9.3832e-06 |
0.000111551 |
9.2988e-05 |
0.000129119 |
|
0.003049 |
2.17166e-05 |
2.08911e-05 |
1.70013e-05 |
2.7271e-05 |
4.75824e-05 |
9.04573e-06 |
0.000102756 |
9.06934e-05 |
8.63274e-05 |
|
0.003907 |
2.9644e-05 |
2.4405e-05 |
2.18322e-05 |
3.7928e-05 |
8.77184e-05 |
1.31074e-05 |
0.000407784 |
0.00013776 |
0.00020224 |
|
0.003336 |
3.32158e-05 |
2.92694e-05 |
2.23226e-05 |
2.9316e-05 |
8.58519e-05 |
1.20384e-05 |
0.000355944 |
0.000276624 |
0.000115003 |
|
0.009006 |
5.01457e-05 |
6.59465e-05 |
6.57939e-05 |
4.6482e-05 |
0.000306515 |
2.74418e-05 |
0.000887201 |
0.000532549 |
0.000212008 |
|
0.006586 |
3.53015e-05 |
4.62261e-05 |
4.03759e-05 |
3.28733e-05 |
0.000230488 |
1.56541e-05 |
0.000577349 |
0.000432744 |
0.000209221 |
|
0.006105 |
4.0656e-05 |
6.19064e-05 |
6.94347e-05 |
3.74189e-05 |
0.000314255 |
2.18478e-05 |
0.001246 |
0.000861271 |
0.000374497 |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Backward Table 3 - Amplitude RMSE
Paper Original
No backward paper-original table is available in the paper.
Paper Retuned
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.004321 |
8.92984e-05 |
7.59251e-05 |
0.000122372 |
5.24986e-05 |
0.00018634 |
4.13104e-05 |
0.002147 |
0.001733 |
0.000768566 |
|
0.023489 |
0.014012 |
0.034222 |
0.016157 |
0.019279 |
0.01215 |
0.018511 |
0.011909 |
0.020039 |
0.01354 |
|
0.003822 |
4.01928e-05 |
3.95792e-05 |
2.41367e-05 |
4.08393e-05 |
7.35254e-05 |
1.45444e-05 |
0.000351421 |
0.000350566 |
0.000143677 |
|
0.004755 |
3.89166e-05 |
4.63022e-05 |
3.5792e-05 |
4.65966e-05 |
0.000141259 |
2.1564e-05 |
0.000458745 |
0.000633652 |
0.000247847 |
|
0.004572 |
3.78036e-05 |
4.05121e-05 |
3.04868e-05 |
4.2643e-05 |
9.56236e-05 |
1.38535e-05 |
0.000333265 |
0.000508611 |
0.000340328 |
|
0.004034 |
3.32592e-05 |
3.37697e-05 |
2.42355e-05 |
3.99313e-05 |
6.91306e-05 |
1.34407e-05 |
0.000318311 |
0.000352948 |
0.000173187 |
|
0.005304 |
4.27122e-05 |
3.50066e-05 |
3.02839e-05 |
5.45847e-05 |
0.000114522 |
2.03896e-05 |
0.002273 |
0.00066182 |
0.000854605 |
|
0.004305 |
5.05026e-05 |
4.01874e-05 |
3.17414e-05 |
4.19043e-05 |
0.000115062 |
1.73374e-05 |
0.00091268 |
0.000819282 |
0.000242704 |
|
0.011001 |
7.54328e-05 |
8.55087e-05 |
8.04608e-05 |
5.83e-05 |
0.00036438 |
3.40776e-05 |
0.001727 |
0.001146 |
0.000500722 |
|
0.008224 |
5.37816e-05 |
5.75288e-05 |
5.02789e-05 |
4.44481e-05 |
0.000274288 |
2.08906e-05 |
0.00103 |
0.000972133 |
0.000415477 |
|
0.007959 |
6.49451e-05 |
8.87046e-05 |
8.60459e-05 |
4.79292e-05 |
0.000405392 |
2.81136e-05 |
0.002354 |
0.001667 |
0.000692278 |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Backward Table 4 - Phase MAE
Paper Original
No backward paper-original table is available in the paper.
Paper Retuned
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.003277 |
0.030147 |
1.533948 |
0.239405 |
0.16531 |
0.165708 |
0.519181 |
0.647235 |
0.934282 |
|
0.012577 |
0.047895 |
0.883528 |
0.223007 |
0.117947 |
0.164507 |
0.550536 |
0.633432 |
0.74779 |
|
0.004475 |
0.020274 |
0.259613 |
0.088339 |
0.055395 |
0.100364 |
0.103195 |
0.104946 |
0.201875 |
|
0.002297 |
0.030949 |
0.264166 |
0.109481 |
0.104082 |
0.131394 |
0.154214 |
0.138677 |
0.272296 |
|
0.002216 |
0.024758 |
0.251627 |
0.12914 |
0.061557 |
0.117384 |
0.137711 |
0.158073 |
0.335381 |
|
0.001928 |
0.022496 |
0.224182 |
0.093953 |
0.05315 |
0.092693 |
0.138368 |
0.099516 |
0.224467 |
|
0.001997 |
0.033333 |
0.32552 |
0.111136 |
0.060508 |
0.119325 |
0.33279 |
0.205319 |
0.423721 |
|
0.004355 |
0.031669 |
0.48239 |
0.11461 |
0.089437 |
0.116216 |
0.251079 |
0.198438 |
0.422011 |
|
0.007236 |
0.105 |
1.368352 |
0.237439 |
0.149121 |
0.154242 |
0.394363 |
0.2798 |
0.74483 |
|
0.003988 |
0.075939 |
1.007733 |
0.159638 |
0.119033 |
0.16781 |
0.347521 |
0.403988 |
0.606608 |
|
0.005351 |
0.095946 |
1.401709 |
0.21804 |
0.14142 |
0.191291 |
0.566196 |
0.85855 |
0.826733 |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Backward Table 5 - Phase RMSE
Paper Original
No backward paper-original table is available in the paper.
Paper Retuned
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
0.004976 |
0.050379 |
1.904003 |
0.390645 |
0.302424 |
0.208329 |
0.96709 |
1.234879 |
1.739106 |
|
0.019934 |
0.061518 |
1.488289 |
0.387442 |
0.157908 |
0.216736 |
0.922763 |
1.028735 |
1.240815 |
|
0.017312 |
0.031548 |
0.925908 |
0.133734 |
0.089557 |
0.134517 |
0.321643 |
0.324612 |
0.495247 |
|
0.00395 |
0.046179 |
1.158681 |
0.159423 |
0.153046 |
0.187845 |
0.411266 |
0.488621 |
0.666233 |
|
0.00377 |
0.037153 |
1.108501 |
0.245136 |
0.110455 |
0.16568 |
0.50731 |
0.556874 |
0.991502 |
|
0.002972 |
0.034339 |
0.766994 |
0.159162 |
0.095696 |
0.127265 |
0.383862 |
0.279082 |
0.516958 |
|
0.00295 |
0.044645 |
1.141662 |
0.180293 |
0.107463 |
0.16886 |
0.988349 |
0.695553 |
1.10418 |
|
0.008257 |
0.042245 |
1.003621 |
0.175671 |
0.164139 |
0.159327 |
0.552074 |
0.448768 |
0.785715 |
|
0.011072 |
0.123145 |
1.59109 |
0.382244 |
0.244668 |
0.191574 |
0.767348 |
0.565452 |
1.226653 |
|
0.006405 |
0.089842 |
1.316174 |
0.239411 |
0.186768 |
0.208583 |
0.68118 |
0.644011 |
0.990548 |
|
0.011728 |
0.12662 |
1.852693 |
0.376851 |
0.186686 |
0.249883 |
0.946219 |
1.157153 |
1.350511 |
RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction
Model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reading Rules
paper originalis immutable paper-side evidence and exists only for forward.paper retunedis the current recovered-original retuned baseline.RCIM Model-Bank Reproductionis closed as the populated repository-owned paper-faithful full-bank reproduction surface for Tables2-5.RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction forward status colors compare against the best of
paper originalandpaper retuned.RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction backward status colors compare against
paper retuned.Later attempts to force all cells green must be documented as separate optimization branches, not as changes to the closed faithful RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction baseline.
A future restricted-dataset RCIM Model-Bank Reproduction rerun should create a new Markdown comparison report that places full-dataset and reduced-dataset Tables
2-5side by side for every dataset-reduction level.